(In case you don't get the title reference)Don't ask me to retrace the series of tangents and furious link-clicking that brought me to this. Let's just say that Wikipedia is a harsh mistress, but she is fair.
Did you know that the legal brothels in Nevada have
restaurant-style menus?
I didn't either. I'm as amused as I am vaguely uncomfortable.
I consider myself, if not a professional pervert, at least an enthusiastic and well-read amateur. And I only know what half the stuff on that list is. Even Google and Wikipedia only helped reveal another 25% or so. I'm half-tempted to call their customer service line or toss them an email, just to fill the gaps (heh) in my...knowledge.
I'm torn when it comes to the issue of sex work. Split, right down the middle.
On one hand, I don't like it on principle. The idea of turning human sexuality into a commodity offends me on a deeply personal level.
It just doesn't seem like a good idea, for all involved. It feels innately dehumanizing, though the degree varies from one situation to the next.
So much misogyny, so much anger and hatred and violence, is expressed through the sex trade. I don't know if that is because the modern sex trade is distorted by the phallocratic rape culture I live in, or if there is something integral to the pratice that taints it at the source.
On the other hand...well, there are two hands on the other side. So my viewpoint on this issue is like some sort of irradiated mutant from the sewers of the 31st century, only with more eyes and fewer tentacles.
I've read accounts of street-corner hookers being beaten and drugged-up by pimps, being stabbed and left for dead in back alleys. I've also read accounts from loving couples who treated themselves to a threesome with a call girl on a Nevada ranch as an anniversary present, expressing their gratitude for a wonderful evening. So this is anything but a simple issue. I've read too many books and blogs, too many letters and memoirs, from the people who actually
do sex work instead of just talking about it, for this to be "simple" for me.
First, the ethics of prostitution are conceptual. The reality is that it happens whether it's legal or not. When it's legal, as it is in Nevada and New Zealand, the prostitutes have rights under the law. They have legally-mandated standards when it comes to working conditions and treatment by employers and customers alike. They can call the police when a customer assaults them, without fear of being taken to jail themselves, without fear of not being taken seriously. Standards are set, and enforced, for sanitation and regular disease screening.
I'm not trying to make it out to be Paradise. It's a job, like any other. For some, it's a fun job. But it's still a job. And while some of them are doing what they love and getting a paycheque in the bargain, others do admit to feeling trapped. Because sex work ultimately will trap you if you let it. The money is too good. Things that seem possible at $200/hour are unthinkable at $10/hour. And as lucrative as it can be, the longer you spend in the sex trades, the more it eats away at your earning potential for any other industry. You can start escorting at 19, then blink and find yourself a 30-year-old with no work experience you can put on a resume for any job that doesn't involve taking your clothes off.
By the way, if you're about to argue that legal prostitution blurs the lines between "rape" and "paying what's owed," then
fuck you. If I pay you to paint my house and you decide not to at the last minute, I am legally entitled to get my money back.
That's it. I am
not allowed to grab your arm, stick a paint brush in your hand, and start moving it up and down. It is absolutely possible to rape a prostitute, regardless of any financial transactions involved.
And in those places where it is legal, guess what?
The sky hasn't fallen yet. Fire and blood aren't raining down to cleanse the Earth of the nonbelievers. The sun still rises in the morning. Cats and dogs (dingos?) haven't put aside their differences. They aren't uniting under a common cause, pooling their resources toward usurping the rule of humanity in between marathon sex sessions.
Second, at the risk of sounding ableist, cripples and freaks need love too. (I'm hoping any disfigured readers will find my candor refreshing enough to not feel insulted.) Let's not beat around the bush here. Whether they're the victim of genetics before birth or injuries and disease after, some people draw the short straw in life and wind up extremely disabled and/or fucking hideous. And a good personality will only get you so far when everyone who sees you either mocks you or feels sorry for you, neither of which is sexy. Unless you have a fetish for humiliation play, or are a self-labeled "
Nice Guy." But I digress. Then there are the people who suffer from mental and developmental disorders that don't necessarily carry a physical marker, like several forms of autism (Asperger's being the shining crown jewel in this particular crown of shit). These people look normal at first, but enduring the uncomfortably-amusing ordeal that is their attempts at social interaction quickly reveal that they don't have the first fucking clue how to deal with people. And it's not their fault, either. So if one of these unfortunate people decides to turn to a professional to ease their loneliness and sate their libido, who am I to judge them, or the professionals who accept their patronage? In this sense, prostitutes really do perform a public service, by giving at least a taste of a fundamental life experience to people who otherwise probably would never have it.
I don't like that prostitution exists. I don't see myself ever hiring a prostitute. But I don't presume to judge a person who wears that particular hat, regardless of their motives. And you shouldn't either. All we can really do is help. Help make sure that the people who choose to practice it enjoy as much safety and dignity as the rest of us. And help the people who want out to get out. But telling them what to do, what to think? Telling them that they're bad or wrong? Punishing them? That doesn't help. That has never helped.